Free Shipping on Orders Over $139 for Most Locations.

Umarex Colt Commander Review

Special thanks to Harwood W. Loomis at The M1911 Pistols Organization (

The new Colt/Umarex Commander 1911 model is a CO2-powered, (simulated) blowback version of the M1911A1. This is the most accurate reproduction of an M1911A1 I have ever seen in a BB gun. It looks and feels real, and it acts real. The experience of shooting this pistol is amazing – and I shot 1911s when I was in the Army.

Colt/Umarex Commander 1911

Colt/Umarex Commander 1911

The level of authenticity is astonishing. One of my pet peeves is fake 1911 air pistols that have swinging triggers. In this one, the trigger slides straight back, just like it should. The slide stop works. It not only swings up and down, it also locks the slide back after the last shot has been fired. The grip safety not only moves, it also functions as it should.

The thumb safety is functional. Like on a real 1911, it can’t be raised unless the hammer is cocked. As is common on air guns, it has markings for “SAFE” and “FIRE” positions. I can live with that if it gets us a properly functional thumb safety.

The barrel is smooth-bore. A smooth-bore barrel simply can’t produce the accuracy of a rifled barrel. But this is a plinking handgun, so accuracy isn’t critical. The advantage is that it shoots readily-available, steel BBs.

The specifications list the barrel length as 4.50 inches, yet the pistol is the size of a 5-inch M1911A1. This is because the muzzle of the .177-inch barrel is set back a half inch from the apparent muzzle at the front of the slide, for a .45 caliber barrel effect. The “muzzle” even has six ribs on the inside to look like the rifling in a real gun barrel.

CO2 and magazine occupy full magazine well.

CO2 and magazine occupy full magazine well.

What makes the new Colt/Umarex Commander an excellent training aid is that so much of the real 1911 manual of arms remains the same on this reproduction. The Commander is loaded using a magazine that occupies the full magazine well in the frame. The CO2 cartridge is loaded into the magazine, with the BBs, and the pistol is loaded by inserting the magazine and racking the slide. Just like in real life.

The pistol is made of metal, so its weight and balance are very close to those of a real 1911.

The trigger was light, with a bit of creep. The Commander uses some of the gas energy to cycle the slide, resulting in a CO2 air pistol that feels more like shooting a .22 caliber rimfire pistol than it does an air gun.

Related Posts

  • Pump Gun Tips and Tricks

    How Altitude and Pressure Affect Your Multi-Pump GunDid you know that altitude and pressure will affect your pump gun...

  • Why Airguns?

    I have the pleasure of speaking to hundreds of folks each year. Many are already hardcore airgunners, but others are ...

  • Umarex Colt Peacemaker Review

    Special thanks to Harwood W. Loomis at The M1911 Pistols Organization ( Remember the Lone Ranger? Retu...

More Posts


Leave a comment

All blog comments are checked prior to publishing

Search for airguns and gear